On the road during lockdown

Here's what motorists should know.

Meet Smokey Nagata

The man behind the legendary twin-turbo V12 Toyota Supra build.

2019 SA Car of the Year: Which top model should grab the coveted title? - Part 1

2018-12-14 10:48

Lance Branquinho

Hyundai Kona silver

Image: Janine Van der Post/Wheels24

From budget models to luxury SUVs, the 2019 SA CA of the Year sees a star-studded line-up vying for the coveted title. Lance Branquinho take a look at each of the finalists.

We’ve separated the 2018 Car of the Year finalists into two groups, splitting the list alphabetically.

2019 SA Car of the Year: Here's what you need to know about the 5 new top car categories

Below is a short analysis of the merits (and demerits) – of each candidate. If you are braai-side this vacation and the car of the year topic flows into conversation, you’ll have some choice facts to field.  Stay tuned for part 2 in next week.

Alfa Romeo Stelvio

Why it might win: Distinctive design an ode to Alfa’s storied history and a brilliantly engineered platform makes Stelvio lighter and more agile than any of its German SUV rivals.

Why it won’t: Exceptionally narrow dealer network and Alfa’s legacy of indifferent product quality cannot be ignored. Italian infotainment user experience in need of a renaissance to become relevant and user-friendly. 

Honda Civic Type R

Why it might win: The world’s fastest front-wheel drive car and in an industry where the manual gearbox needs saving, the Type R is a hero for those who believe in double de-clutching.

Quirky Japanese but very undiluted in its performance. Two-litre turbo motors can be ferocious and the six-speed manual is a tremendous mechanical interface – for those who value and have the skill to self-shift a high-performance car.

Why it won’t: Not a comfortable day-to-day driver and slower than all its German 2-litre rivals. Doesn’t feature any breakthrough drivetrain or torque vectoring technology.

A charming driver’s car, but not a wildly advanced one. Difficult to fathom the nomination. Outrageous styling aside, it doesn’t redefine the segment. Front-wheel drive is a novelty with 228kW, but beyond that and a charmingly mechanical six-speed gearshift, there’s not much. 

Hyundai Kona

Why it might win: Traditional Hyundai values (generous equipment, build quality) in an uncharacteristically striking design. The i30 is a regarded platform and this is a high-riding i30. If you want to be different, but safe in the knowledge that very little will go wrong with your crossover, this is a good choice.

Why it won’t: Styling might be too daring for some and has the risk of dating badly in a season or two. The South African specification Kona doesn’t feature the multi-link rear suspension available in other markets, dulling the polish of its dynamics.

Lexus 250ES

Why it might win: Lexus by name, but global Toyota Camry eight-generation platform by nature. Not fast, but very generously equipped sedan and possibly the quietest cruising cabin environment in a sub-R1m car. Lexus quality and customer experience promises – as always – to offer a completely unburdened ownership prospect.

Why it won’t: A victory would be implausibly difficult to justify with VW’s Arteon competing in the same segment. Annoyingly fiddly infotainment interface. A naturally-aspirated engine is efficient, but you won’t be overtaking trucking traffic on impulse – especially at Gauteng motoring altitudes. 

Mercedes-Benz A250

Why it might win: Enormous improvement on the previous A-Class in terms of mechanical structure and ride quality. MBUX infotainment and driver assistance systems are futuristic technology made real, by Mercedes, for the hatchback segment.

A250’s 2-litre engine and an evolved version of Mercedes-Benz’s seven-speed dual-clutch transmission make for a very adaptable blend of hot hatchback performance and cruising economy. 

Why it won’t: Expensive. C-Pillar blind spots remain, as does claustrophobia for rear-seat passengers. Silver coloured plastic, masquerading as imitation metal, doesn’t make for a premium cabin architecture.  

Mitsubishi Pajero Sport

Why it might win: Mitsubishi build quality and legacy off-road ability. Pajero Sport’s Super-select 4x4 system remains the class standard for those who require their family off-road wagon to go where others can’t. Ability to run a locked centre-differential in high-range makes it a terrific extreme dune field exploration vehicle.

Why it won’t: Ford’s Everest and Toyota’s Fortuner weren’t considered worthy in previous years, so it would be unlikely for Pajero Sport to win this round of COTY. Abysmally asymmetric rear styling. 


There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.