Share

'Tesla is still doomed' - former GM executive

Detroit -Tesla's swift rise to both create and dominate the luxury all-electric car market has stunned the 2016 Detroit auto show.

To hold its lead to the next plateau - the self-driving, mass-market electric car widely seen as the future of the auto industry - founder Elon Musk is rapidly staffing up with the best talent he can find - computer programmers.

Rather than look to Detroit for help to build his cars, Musk's 12-year-old company is focused on Silicon Valley to recruit some 1600 software engineers for the next stage.

Self-driving push

They are to help develop Autopilot, Tesla's autonomous car IT system, with capabilities like the Summon function announced this week that can allow Tesla owners to call the car from the garage to their side at will, like a pet.

In a sign of his determination to beat Detroit at its own game, last November Musk used Twitter to get his message out.

He said: "We are looking for hardcore software engineers. No prior experience with cars require. Should mention that I will be interviewing people personally and Autopilot reports directly to me. This is a super high priority."

Autopilot is crucial if Tesla aims to have a fully self-driving car by 2018, and increase production 10-fold to 500 000 cars a year by 2020.

Ramping-up production to that level, supported by Tesla's own battery plant under construction in Nevada, is crucial to lowering the price of its cars to a more affordable level, perhaps $35 000, for the Tesla Model 3 electric sedan planned for 2017 - around a third of today's price tag.

Such promises have kept financiers and investors still firmly behind Tesla, even though the Palo Alto, California company has continued to lose money while the big automakers in Detroit rack up profits on the booming US auto market.

Tough competition

If it meets its goals, Tesla could remain a player in the industry. But it is surrounded by likewise eager competitors. All of the large Asian, European and US automakers are ramping up their work on electric, driver-less cars.

Crossing into the field with their substantial resources and tech capabilities are Internet giants like Google, Apple, and Uber.

Also crowding into the race are Tesla-wannabes: startups like Chinese-backed Faraday Future, which unveiled its own Batmobile-looking electric in Las Vegas last week, Karma Automotive, Atieva and NexTex.

All of them appear to agree that the future of the industry is in electric cars that can drive themselves. And they are all battling for the best brainpower Silicon Valley has to offer.

Can Tesla still lead?

Tesla has a march on the competition; the question is whether it can hold on.

Its Model S and new Model X SUV both have Autopilot capabilities which allow hands-off driving in some situations, and it promises incremental expansions of those capabilities.

But rivals loom in the all-electric field that will test Tesla even before autonomous driving gains traction on the roads. Audi's Q6 e-Tron promises a 500km range without charging by 2018, 50% more than Tesla's cars currently.

Mercedes-Benz has its GLE hybrid and BMW the X5. Porsche is putting $1 billion into its "Mission E" electric car and Aston Martin has an electric sports car based on its DBX concept targeted for 2019.

Jessica Caldwell, an industry analyst at Edmunds.com, said: "This is going to be very tough for Tesla. Porsche is an established name. They have a lot of marketing money, they have a lot of credibility, they have a strong dealer network... You can say the same for Audi."

At the more affordable end, General Motors is rushing to market the Chevrolet Bolt, to arrive next year as a challenger to Tesla's Model 3. In the same price range, too, there is already BMW's mini-electric i3.

Karl Brauer, an analyst at Kelley Blue Book, says Tesla "has the cachet, they have the prestige the competition doesn't have. Tesla is the Apple of the automotive industry."

Even so, he warned, to hold its lead, Tesla needs to keep an eye on the calendar as well as innovate. The new Model X was around two years late on its original timeline.

'Tesla is still doomed'

Former GM executive Bob Lutz thinks Tesla, as it bleeds money, is a poor bet to win the race for the car of the future.

"Tesla is still doomed," he said. "Whatever uniqueness they have it's disappearing... They have to learn how to make money like other car companies."

We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
Who we choose to trust can have a profound impact on our lives. Join thousands of devoted South Africans who look to News24 to bring them news they can trust every day. As we celebrate 25 years, become a News24 subscriber as we strive to keep you informed, inspired and empowered.
Join News24 today
heading
description
username
Show Comments ()
Editorial feedback and complaints

Contact the public editor with feedback for our journalists, complaints, queries or suggestions about articles on News24.

LEARN MORE